Workpuls Teramind ActivTrak Hubstaff DeskTime Time Doctor RescueTime Kickidler Veriato Work Examiner
OVERVIEW
Price $6/user/month $6/user/month $7.20/user/month $7/user/month $7/user/month $9.99/user/month $6/user/month $9.99/user/month $150/licence/year $60/licence (lifetime)
Free trial 7 days 7 days No 14 days 14 days 14 days 30 days 7 days Yes 30 days
Ease of use Very easy Difficult Very easy Easy Easy Very easy Very easy Very easy Very difficult Easy
TRACKING METHODS
Unlimited (tracker working 24/7)
Fixed (defined working hours)
Automatic (when computer is connected to a specified network)
Manual (start/stop)
Project based (track time only on projects)
GENERAL MONITORING FEATURES
Stealth mode
App and website usage
Real-time monitoring
Offline time tracking
Attendance
Activity levels
Keylogger
Geolocation
Remote desktop control
Website/activity blocking
SCREENSHOTS AND RECORDING
Screenshots
Screenshots on demand
Screen recording
PRODUCTIVITY FEATURES
Productivity trends
Websites and apps labeling
Category labeling
Productivity alerts
ADVANCED SECURITY FEATURES
User behavior analytics
Data loss prevention
Advanced file and web monitoring
REPORTING
Productivity reports
Team reports
Timelines
Email reports
Access management
PLATFORMS
Web
Mac desktop app
Windows desktop app
Linux desktop app
Mobile app iOS, Android iOS, Android iOS, Android iOS, Android iOS, Android Android
Browser extension Chrome Chrome Chrome
Other Citrix, VMware Chrome OS
OTHER
Support Phone, email, online Phone, email, online Phone, email, online Email, online Phone, email, online, in-person Online Phone, email, online Email, online, Viber, Whatsapp Phone, email, online, support ticket Phone, email, online
Knowledge base
Video tutorials
Integrations comming soon
API
Deployment cloud, on-premise cloud, on-premise, AWS, Azure cloud cloud cloud cloud cloud on-premise cloud, on-premise on-premise
Kronos Humanity Timeclockplus Tsheets Wheniwork Deputy Replicon Jibble EbilityTimeTracker OnTheClock BeeBole
OVERVIEW
Price(per month)Available upon requestFrom $2 per userAvailable upon requestFrom $6.40 per user+$16Free for up to 75 usersFrom $2.50 per userBasic plan:$30 for 5 users+$5 per additional userFrom $1.50 per employeeFrom $4 per user+$8From $2.20 per user$5.99 per user per month
Free trial30 days14 daysYes14 days14 days14 days30 days30 days,no credit card required
Ease of useDifficultEasyDifficultVery easyEasyEasyDifficultVery easyEasyEasyEasy
FEATURES
Timecard management
Scheduling
Shift Trading
Timesheets
Break time management
Real-time tracking
PTO Management
Payroll
Invoicing
Client billing
GPS tracking
Clock out reminders
Alerts
Manual time
PUNCH-IN METHODS
Web app
Mobile app
Time clock device
Time clock kiosk
Facial recognition
Fingerprint scanning
Geofencing
Group punch-in
REPORTING
Visual reports
Email reports
Time rounding
MANAGEMENT
Permissions
Manager approvals
Add time for others
Integrations
PLATFORMS
Web
Android app
iOS app
Mac desktop app
Windows desktop app
Linux desktop app
OTHER
SupportPhone and onlinePhone and onlinePhone,chat and onlinePhone and chatEmail and onlineChat and phonePhone,email,chat and onlinePhone and onlinePhone,email,chat and onlinePhone and onlineOnline chat and video support in English,French,and Spanish
Knowledge base
Video tutorials
Community forum
API
Workpuls Hubstaff Toggl TimeDoctor Harvest TimeCamp Timely Everhour Tick TMetric
OVERVIEW
Price (per month) $6 per user $5.83 per user $9 per user $9.99 per user $10.80 per user $5.25 per user $99 for 5 users $7 per user $19 for 10 projects $5 per user
Free trial 7 days 14 days 30 days 14 days 30 days Yes 14 days 14 days 30 days 30 days
Ease of use Very easy Difficult Difficult Very easy Easy Very easy Easy Difficult Very easy Difficult
TIME TRACKING METHODS
Manual
Start/stop buttons
Automatic time mapping
IN-DEPTH TASK AND PROJECT ANALYSIS
Screenshots
App and website usage
Activity levels coming soon
Real-time tracking
TASK AND PROJECT MANAGEMENT
Project adding
Project templates
Project status
Task assignment
Task priorities
Budgeting coming soon
Mark billable/non-billable hours
Payroll calculation
Invoicing
ALERTS
Idle time reminders
Deadline alerts coming soon
Budget alerts coming soon
REPORTING
Client login
Productivity analysis
Email reports coming soon
PLATFORMS
Web
Mac desktop app
Windows desktop app
Linux desktop app coming soon
iOS app Beta
Android app
Browser extension Chrome Chrome, Firefox Chrome Chrome Chrome, Firefox Chrome Chrome, Firefox, Opera, Edge
OTHER
Support Phone and online Email and online Email and online Online Online, email and phone Email, online and support ticket Email and chat Email and chat Email Chat
Knowledge base
Video tutorials
Integrations coming soon
API
On-premise hosting

Key Takeaways:

  • Process mining offers a clear view of your organization's workflows by analyzing digital footprints, which helps identify inefficiencies and bottlenecks.

  • To implement process mining successfully, start by gathering and organizing data from your systems, then select a suitable tool that aligns with your infrastructure and team capabilities.

  • Successful deployment involves collaborative efforts with IT experts and stakeholders, focusing on pragmatic pilot projects to demonstrate value and build momentum.

  • Process mining requires a commitment to transparency and a culture of continuous improvement, adapting processes as the business evolves.

  • The true power of process mining lies in its ability to represent exactly how work gets done, fostering agility and resilience in your operations.

Read time: 8 minutes

When overseeing operations and monitoring employee performance, leaders often find themselves caught in a whirlwind that leaves them with a lingering sense of unrest. 

This undercurrent of dissatisfaction is fueled by the suspicion that surely there are untapped avenues that can enhance efficiency and streamline workflows. 

But when you're knee-deep in the day-to-day operations, it's tough to take a step back and see the bigger picture to check if everything's running as smoothly as it should. 

It’s like staring at a puzzle with a piece missing but not having a moment's peace to find it.

If only the inefficiencies could be quickly identified, it would save a great deal of time, resources, energy, and frustration. If you’ve ever felt handcuffed by the lack of time or the appropriate tools to pinpoint these improvements, you're not alone.

That's exactly where process mining steps in. 

Think of it this way: every work-related activity, from sending an email to closing a sale, leaves a digital trace. Process mining picks up all the digital crumbs and lays them out in a way that makes sense. 

Instead of drowning in information, you see a clear, actionable path to real insights. Visualizing the workflow within your organization can help spot any hiccups or inefficiencies more quickly.

If you're eager to streamline your operations and explore new technology that helps you see the bigger picture, diving into process mining sooner rather than later is a smart move. 

What is process mining?

​​Process mining analyzes business processes based on data from event logs in various IT systems. Rather than a single tool for monitoring remote teams and their output, it’s more like technology that can be implemented through various software solutions. The data science technique renders a transparent and accurate visualization of all business processes. 

The main goal of process mining is to uncover how business processes occur in real life, identify bottlenecks, and find opportunities for improvement.

Does your organization need process mining?

Are you striving to enhance operational efficiency?

Do you need to improve customer experiences with better service delivery?

Are you looking to create a culture of continuous improvement?

Do you need more data-driven decision-making?

Are you considering digital transformation initiatives?

If you answered yes to any of these questions, then process mining may be exactly what your business needs. 

What are the benefits of process mining?

Process mining can enhance multiple operational aspects. It’s like a comprehensive toolkit, assembled to create a cohesive strategy for business improvement:

  • Operational Efficiency: Process mining simplifies operations by finding and fixing any inefficiencies. This helps businesses ’’achieve more with less’’ and speed up work processes.

  • Compliance & Auditing: The technique makes sure all business activities are in line with laws and company rules. As a result, companies can avoid legal issues and maintain trust.

  • Customer Experience: Process mining can make the customer journey smoother and more enjoyable by examining how customers interact with services. This leads to improved customer satisfaction and retention.

  • Change Management: Using this technique, companies can smoothly introduce new methodologies with clear demonstrations. If everyone can see exactly what’s changing, they can adapt more easily.

  • Digital Transformation Guidance: Process mining points out where technology can make a real difference, ensuring that investments in digital upgrades truly pay off.

How does process mining work?

Let's break it down in simple terms. Imagine every time you send an email, approve a task, or complete a transaction, you leave a digital footprint. Process mining takes these footprints and stitches them together to map out the real workflow in your organization.

It starts with gathering data from your IT systems. This isn't just any data—it’s specific to the tasks and activities that make up your business processes. Once collected, the data gets organized in a way that makes sense for analysis.

The next step is where the magic happens. Using sophisticated algorithms, process mining tools visualize business processes, showing you not just the ideal workflow but how work actually gets done.

Process mining doesn't stop at visualization. The real value comes from analyzing the data to pinpoint where things are falling short. Are there any unnecessary steps? Delays between tasks? The analysis brings those issues to light, offering the insights needed to make targeted improvements.

Process mining detangles your business operations, turning what might seem like a black box into a clear, understandable roadmap. It's a straightforward yet powerful approach to making your business processes leaner, faster, and more efficient.

Let’s take a look at a simplified example of process mining in action to streamline financial processes:

  • Digital Footprints: Every invoice generated, approved, and paid generates data within financial management systems.

  • Data Gathering: Process mining tools extract this data to analyze the financial operations thoroughly.

  • Visualization: A detailed map of the financial workflows, such as accounts payable and receivable processes, is created, showing the real versus expected processes.

  • Analysis: This might uncover delays in invoice approvals or payments, or even identify steps that could be automated to reduce manual intervention.

  • Improvement: With these insights, a business can enhance its financial operations by automating certain approvals, improving communication between departments, or training staff on efficient practices, thus reducing costs and improving cash flow.

What process mining tools do I need?

Process mining typically involves specialized software tools designed to handle extracting, transforming, and analyzing event log data to visualize and improve business processes. 

While it's possible to perform some aspects of process mining with basic data analysis and visualization tools, it’s not the best solution. The specialized nature of process mining tasks—such as process discovery, conformance checking, and process enhancement—usually requires dedicated tools. 

Some specialized process mining tools include Celonis, UiPath Process Mining (formerly ProcessGold), Disco (by Fluxicon), and Signavio Process Intelligence. 

Process mining tools automatically generate process models, check their conformance with ideal models, suggest enhancements, and identify inefficiencies, serving as a critical first step in the optimization journey.

What are process optimization tools?

Once process mining tools have identified areas for improvement, process optimization tools come into play, using the insights to implement changes, streamline operations, and enhance overall efficiency. 

Combining process optimization tools with process mining can create a synergistic effect, resulting in more effective business operations. So, which tools work best for process optimization?

Process Improvement & Automation Tools

Business process management (BPM) tools like Appian, Pega, and Bizagi form the foundation for process optimization, especially when paired with automation tools such as Zapier, Microsoft Power Automate, and UiPath. The joint effort of these tools can design, refine, and automate workflows using insights from process mining.

Data Analysis & Visualization Tools

Data analytics platforms like Tableau, Power BI, and Google Analytics can further analyze the data uncovered by process mining. These tools provide advanced visualization and deeper insights into process performance, helping to identify trends and patterns that may not be immediately apparent through process mining alone.

Project & Task Management Tools

Asana, Trello, and Jira can help manage the projects and initiatives that arise from process mining insights. These tools ensure that process improvement projects are executed on time, within budget, and in alignment with the desired outcomes identified through process mining.

Customer Relationship Management (CRM) Systems 

CRM platforms like Salesforce, HubSpot, and Zoho CRM can use the customer journey and insights gained from process mining to optimize customer interactions and service delivery. In turn, this enhances customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) Systems

ERP systems such as SAP, Oracle, and Microsoft Dynamics can integrate process mining insights to optimize cross-departmental processes. This holistic view ensures that improvements are aligned across the organization, maximizing operational efficiency and resource utilization.

Document Management Systems (DMS)

DMS platforms like M-Files and DocuWare can be optimized based on process mining insights to enhance document flow, accessibility, and compliance within business processes. This significantly reduces bottlenecks related to document handling.

Workforce Analytics Tools

Insightful, a top employee monitoring software with enhanced capabilities for remote employee productivity monitoring provides a detailed analysis of team efficiency, which can be invaluable for process mining. Once you understand how employees interact with existing processes, you can tailor process improvements to better fit the workforce. This will lead to higher adoption rates and more effective process changes.

To see what these tools look like in action, check out our article on process mining and optimization tools.

How do I implement process mining? 

Process mining can propel your operational efficiency to new heights with a crystal-clear view of business processes. However, implementing it in your organization is not as simple as flipping a switch. 

It starts with your data. 

The first step involves gathering and organizing the digital footprints from your systems—be it your CRM, ERP, or other operational tools. This data is the lifeblood of process mining since it reveals the true nature of your workflows.

Select the right tool.

Find a platform that brings out the nuances in your data but also aligns with your team's capabilities and long-term vision. The right tool can uncover paths to efficiency that were previously buried under a mountain of data.

The market offers a wide range of options, each with its unique strengths. Look for a solution that aligns with your tech infrastructure and is intuitive enough for your team to use. Compatibility and user-friendliness will greatly influence the success of your process mining initiative.

For more information on how to choose the right tools, check out our article on process mining and optimization tools.

Effective deployment is crucial.

Deployment should be a collaborative effort that also involves the stakeholders of various business processes. These individuals will play a key role in interpreting the data and translating insights into practical improvements.

Process mining requires a pragmatic approach, especially in the initial steps. Identify a core process that is vital to your operations yet manageable in scope. This pilot project will demonstrate the value of process mining with a tangible success story, making a stronger case for wider adoption within your organization.

When you first dig into process mining, it's important to remain enthusiastic and practical. Starting small allows you to celebrate early wins, build momentum, and learn valuable lessons without overwhelming your team or resources. These early wins set the stage for a broader use of process mining throughout the entire organization, maximizing its benefits.

Focus on process optimization continually. 

To implement process mining successfully, you need to commit to transparency. That means being willing to face the truth about your processes and go from ’’this is how we think things are done’’ to ’’okay, this is what’s actually happening.’’

Ultimately, adaptability is the true power that comes from process mining. As your business grows and the market landscape shifts, your processes will need to evolve too. Process mining provides the agility to navigate these changes, ensuring that your operations remain resilient, responsive, and aligned with your strategic goals.

This shift requires embracing new technology but also a mindset change across the organization. You need to create an environment where continuous improvement is not just encouraged but ingrained in the company ethos.

We’ve reserved a 7-day free trial for you….

Want your hybrid or remote team to be more productive?

Claim your free 7-Day full feature trial of Insightful today. Insightful’s actionable work insights make your team more productive, efficient and accountable.

Ready to Take Full Control Of Your Workplace?

Try the simplest solution today…

Start Free Trial
Process Optimization

Process Mining is Transforming Business Operations - Here’s How Your Business Can Benefit

Written by
Sonja Glisic
Published on
March 15, 2024

Key Takeaways:

  • Process mining offers a clear view of your organization's workflows by analyzing digital footprints, which helps identify inefficiencies and bottlenecks.

  • To implement process mining successfully, start by gathering and organizing data from your systems, then select a suitable tool that aligns with your infrastructure and team capabilities.

  • Successful deployment involves collaborative efforts with IT experts and stakeholders, focusing on pragmatic pilot projects to demonstrate value and build momentum.

  • Process mining requires a commitment to transparency and a culture of continuous improvement, adapting processes as the business evolves.

  • The true power of process mining lies in its ability to represent exactly how work gets done, fostering agility and resilience in your operations.

Read time: 8 minutes

When overseeing operations and monitoring employee performance, leaders often find themselves caught in a whirlwind that leaves them with a lingering sense of unrest. 

This undercurrent of dissatisfaction is fueled by the suspicion that surely there are untapped avenues that can enhance efficiency and streamline workflows. 

But when you're knee-deep in the day-to-day operations, it's tough to take a step back and see the bigger picture to check if everything's running as smoothly as it should. 

It’s like staring at a puzzle with a piece missing but not having a moment's peace to find it.

If only the inefficiencies could be quickly identified, it would save a great deal of time, resources, energy, and frustration. If you’ve ever felt handcuffed by the lack of time or the appropriate tools to pinpoint these improvements, you're not alone.

That's exactly where process mining steps in. 

Think of it this way: every work-related activity, from sending an email to closing a sale, leaves a digital trace. Process mining picks up all the digital crumbs and lays them out in a way that makes sense. 

Instead of drowning in information, you see a clear, actionable path to real insights. Visualizing the workflow within your organization can help spot any hiccups or inefficiencies more quickly.

If you're eager to streamline your operations and explore new technology that helps you see the bigger picture, diving into process mining sooner rather than later is a smart move. 

What is process mining?

​​Process mining analyzes business processes based on data from event logs in various IT systems. Rather than a single tool for monitoring remote teams and their output, it’s more like technology that can be implemented through various software solutions. The data science technique renders a transparent and accurate visualization of all business processes. 

The main goal of process mining is to uncover how business processes occur in real life, identify bottlenecks, and find opportunities for improvement.

Does your organization need process mining?

Are you striving to enhance operational efficiency?

Do you need to improve customer experiences with better service delivery?

Are you looking to create a culture of continuous improvement?

Do you need more data-driven decision-making?

Are you considering digital transformation initiatives?

If you answered yes to any of these questions, then process mining may be exactly what your business needs. 

What are the benefits of process mining?

Process mining can enhance multiple operational aspects. It’s like a comprehensive toolkit, assembled to create a cohesive strategy for business improvement:

  • Operational Efficiency: Process mining simplifies operations by finding and fixing any inefficiencies. This helps businesses ’’achieve more with less’’ and speed up work processes.

  • Compliance & Auditing: The technique makes sure all business activities are in line with laws and company rules. As a result, companies can avoid legal issues and maintain trust.

  • Customer Experience: Process mining can make the customer journey smoother and more enjoyable by examining how customers interact with services. This leads to improved customer satisfaction and retention.

  • Change Management: Using this technique, companies can smoothly introduce new methodologies with clear demonstrations. If everyone can see exactly what’s changing, they can adapt more easily.

  • Digital Transformation Guidance: Process mining points out where technology can make a real difference, ensuring that investments in digital upgrades truly pay off.

How does process mining work?

Let's break it down in simple terms. Imagine every time you send an email, approve a task, or complete a transaction, you leave a digital footprint. Process mining takes these footprints and stitches them together to map out the real workflow in your organization.

It starts with gathering data from your IT systems. This isn't just any data—it’s specific to the tasks and activities that make up your business processes. Once collected, the data gets organized in a way that makes sense for analysis.

The next step is where the magic happens. Using sophisticated algorithms, process mining tools visualize business processes, showing you not just the ideal workflow but how work actually gets done.

Process mining doesn't stop at visualization. The real value comes from analyzing the data to pinpoint where things are falling short. Are there any unnecessary steps? Delays between tasks? The analysis brings those issues to light, offering the insights needed to make targeted improvements.

Process mining detangles your business operations, turning what might seem like a black box into a clear, understandable roadmap. It's a straightforward yet powerful approach to making your business processes leaner, faster, and more efficient.

Let’s take a look at a simplified example of process mining in action to streamline financial processes:

  • Digital Footprints: Every invoice generated, approved, and paid generates data within financial management systems.

  • Data Gathering: Process mining tools extract this data to analyze the financial operations thoroughly.

  • Visualization: A detailed map of the financial workflows, such as accounts payable and receivable processes, is created, showing the real versus expected processes.

  • Analysis: This might uncover delays in invoice approvals or payments, or even identify steps that could be automated to reduce manual intervention.

  • Improvement: With these insights, a business can enhance its financial operations by automating certain approvals, improving communication between departments, or training staff on efficient practices, thus reducing costs and improving cash flow.

What process mining tools do I need?

Process mining typically involves specialized software tools designed to handle extracting, transforming, and analyzing event log data to visualize and improve business processes. 

While it's possible to perform some aspects of process mining with basic data analysis and visualization tools, it’s not the best solution. The specialized nature of process mining tasks—such as process discovery, conformance checking, and process enhancement—usually requires dedicated tools. 

Some specialized process mining tools include Celonis, UiPath Process Mining (formerly ProcessGold), Disco (by Fluxicon), and Signavio Process Intelligence. 

Process mining tools automatically generate process models, check their conformance with ideal models, suggest enhancements, and identify inefficiencies, serving as a critical first step in the optimization journey.

What are process optimization tools?

Once process mining tools have identified areas for improvement, process optimization tools come into play, using the insights to implement changes, streamline operations, and enhance overall efficiency. 

Combining process optimization tools with process mining can create a synergistic effect, resulting in more effective business operations. So, which tools work best for process optimization?

Process Improvement & Automation Tools

Business process management (BPM) tools like Appian, Pega, and Bizagi form the foundation for process optimization, especially when paired with automation tools such as Zapier, Microsoft Power Automate, and UiPath. The joint effort of these tools can design, refine, and automate workflows using insights from process mining.

Data Analysis & Visualization Tools

Data analytics platforms like Tableau, Power BI, and Google Analytics can further analyze the data uncovered by process mining. These tools provide advanced visualization and deeper insights into process performance, helping to identify trends and patterns that may not be immediately apparent through process mining alone.

Project & Task Management Tools

Asana, Trello, and Jira can help manage the projects and initiatives that arise from process mining insights. These tools ensure that process improvement projects are executed on time, within budget, and in alignment with the desired outcomes identified through process mining.

Customer Relationship Management (CRM) Systems 

CRM platforms like Salesforce, HubSpot, and Zoho CRM can use the customer journey and insights gained from process mining to optimize customer interactions and service delivery. In turn, this enhances customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) Systems

ERP systems such as SAP, Oracle, and Microsoft Dynamics can integrate process mining insights to optimize cross-departmental processes. This holistic view ensures that improvements are aligned across the organization, maximizing operational efficiency and resource utilization.

Document Management Systems (DMS)

DMS platforms like M-Files and DocuWare can be optimized based on process mining insights to enhance document flow, accessibility, and compliance within business processes. This significantly reduces bottlenecks related to document handling.

Workforce Analytics Tools

Insightful, a top employee monitoring software with enhanced capabilities for remote employee productivity monitoring provides a detailed analysis of team efficiency, which can be invaluable for process mining. Once you understand how employees interact with existing processes, you can tailor process improvements to better fit the workforce. This will lead to higher adoption rates and more effective process changes.

To see what these tools look like in action, check out our article on process mining and optimization tools.

How do I implement process mining? 

Process mining can propel your operational efficiency to new heights with a crystal-clear view of business processes. However, implementing it in your organization is not as simple as flipping a switch. 

It starts with your data. 

The first step involves gathering and organizing the digital footprints from your systems—be it your CRM, ERP, or other operational tools. This data is the lifeblood of process mining since it reveals the true nature of your workflows.

Select the right tool.

Find a platform that brings out the nuances in your data but also aligns with your team's capabilities and long-term vision. The right tool can uncover paths to efficiency that were previously buried under a mountain of data.

The market offers a wide range of options, each with its unique strengths. Look for a solution that aligns with your tech infrastructure and is intuitive enough for your team to use. Compatibility and user-friendliness will greatly influence the success of your process mining initiative.

For more information on how to choose the right tools, check out our article on process mining and optimization tools.

Effective deployment is crucial.

Deployment should be a collaborative effort that also involves the stakeholders of various business processes. These individuals will play a key role in interpreting the data and translating insights into practical improvements.

Process mining requires a pragmatic approach, especially in the initial steps. Identify a core process that is vital to your operations yet manageable in scope. This pilot project will demonstrate the value of process mining with a tangible success story, making a stronger case for wider adoption within your organization.

When you first dig into process mining, it's important to remain enthusiastic and practical. Starting small allows you to celebrate early wins, build momentum, and learn valuable lessons without overwhelming your team or resources. These early wins set the stage for a broader use of process mining throughout the entire organization, maximizing its benefits.

Focus on process optimization continually. 

To implement process mining successfully, you need to commit to transparency. That means being willing to face the truth about your processes and go from ’’this is how we think things are done’’ to ’’okay, this is what’s actually happening.’’

Ultimately, adaptability is the true power that comes from process mining. As your business grows and the market landscape shifts, your processes will need to evolve too. Process mining provides the agility to navigate these changes, ensuring that your operations remain resilient, responsive, and aligned with your strategic goals.

This shift requires embracing new technology but also a mindset change across the organization. You need to create an environment where continuous improvement is not just encouraged but ingrained in the company ethos.